Golf Irons Forged Vs Cast: Are Forged or Cast Irons Better?


** Dunedin Golf is supported by readers. We may earn a commission when you buy with our links — thank you!

Golf Irons Forged Vs Cast

There has always been a heated debate over golf irons forged vs cast about which choice is the best? 

Is forged iron or cast iron preferable? The most comprehensive answer is that it varies from player to player. 

But first, let’s examine the differences between developed and cast irons and some common misconceptions about both before determining which kind of iron is ideal for your game.

Let’s get to it!

What Are These Golf Irons, And How Are They Different?

Casting and forging are the two procedures used by golf club designers and engineers to transform raw material into a clubhead. Casting entails pouring molten metal into a mold while forging entails pressing metal into the desired shape. 

Combining cast and forged components on the same clubhead is also conceivable and is becoming increasingly popular. There were substantial differences between forged and cast irons when the material was initially developed. 

That is to say, the gap between the two is now much narrower than it used to be. No matter how you look at it, there are still a few inevitable differences between forging and casting iron when it comes to performance.

There is still considerable ignorance and confusion about the differences between cast and forged irons based on the customer reviews. This article will explain the essential differences between the two approaches and the pros and cons of each technique.

See also Do Golf Irons Wear Out?

Forged Golf Iron

Mizuno Golf JPX921 Forged Iron Set

During forging, the material is often heated while staying in a solid state and then pressed into the shape needed by the task. We will wear our material engineering hats to provide a more detailed explanation.

Because forged irons, also known as players’ irons, have been around for the most extended amount of time, their design has remained more traditional. 

Forged steel surpasses cast steel in several applications.

Forging irons are formed from a single piece of solid metal, and you’ll see how this differs from casting irons later in this article. 

Following the manufacturer’s standards, this solid piece of metal is stamped to get the correct form and loft by following the manufacturer’s instructions.

Cast Golf Iron

Callaway Golf 2020 Mavrik Iron

Cast golf irons are made by pouring molten metal into a preformed mold that has been prepared before the production process begins. 

Instead of liquid metal, solid metal is used in the forging process. Are you following what I’m trying to convey now?

As opposed to forged irons, cast or cavity back irons are a more recent design. 

Cast iron clubs were regarded as a non-viable choice for golfers in the early days of golf club creation and production when blacksmiths were in control of the process. 

Golf clubs have become far more forgiving due to the discovery of cast golf clubs, which is a significant advancement in the game.

Cast irons, unlike forged irons, are made by pouring molten metal into a mold that has already been created. 

Cast irons are designed from molten metal that has already been formed, while forged irons are fashioned from a solid piece of metal. 

As opposed to forged irons, cast irons are more pliable, enabling technical components such as perimeter weighting, channels, and cavities to be included in the construction. 

Molten metal, unlike forged iron, is flexible and can be poured into a wide variety of pre-molded shapes more easily than forged iron.

Pros And Cons of Forged Golf Iron

Here are some pros and cons of a forged golf iron.

Pros

  • A piece of steel is pounded and rolled hundreds of times before it can turn into a usable golf club for use.
  • In recent years, they have become more forgiving.
  • Because there is no technology to assist you, you will be able to control your shorts much more quickly while using forged clubs.
  • Muscle-back and blade constructions are standard in forged irons and other designs. They have a small footprint and a straightforward method.

Cons

  • Expensive
  • In terms of performance, but a bit more pressure on the player.

Pros And Cons of Cast Golf Iron

Here are some pros and cons of a cast golf iron.

Pros

  • In addition, since the metal in cast clubs does not have to be handled during the manufacturing process, you may use a far wider variety of steel to manufacture these clubs.
  • A lower center of gravity than the norm allows you to move more freely.
  • Those with less developed abilities will benefit from working with cast irons because of their forgiving nature.
  • The enhanced ball speed, which results in improved launch and distance, makes it possible to strike your shots from almost any spot on the course.

Cons

  • The experience is not always as pleasant.

Golf Irons Forged Vs Cast: Comparison

Here’s a comparison of the two irons that you should know.

Distance

The forged vs cast iron’s distance is one of the biggest points in comparing these two golf irons. 

One thing is certain: forged irons outperform cast irons in terms of feel and distance control, but cast irons outperform forged irons in terms of durability and distance gain over the long haul.

Durability And Strength

Even while cast components are not inherently weak, forgings are much more durable than cast parts. 

Calculating how much stronger something is may be difficult because it relies on a wide range of variables.  

Discoloration happens more rapidly and visibly when using forged irons than cast irons. This is not to be confused with the grooves on forged irons worn.

Performance

Forged components often outperform cast parts in strength, with the developed item typically exceeding the cast item by 25 to 50%. 

Moreover, cast goods are more delicate than forged ones, which is another advantage of generating over castings. 

The continuous grain structure allows it to be bent further before splitting, boosting its tensile and overall strength.

Availability

Forged iron is the more common kind of iron. These irons were formerly rather unique in appearance, but as time has passed, they have grown more and more similar in look to one another in terms of design. 

While some people feel that forged iron is preferable to cast iron, others believe this without fully grasping the differences between the two materials.

Unless you are a true novice in the truest sense of the term, try not to get too caught up with the question of whether the club is forged or cast. 

Consider, instead, what kind of weighting features could be most suited for the forgiveness vs. workability requirements that your game is most likely to face.

Other Popular Comparisons Articles

Simply select a comparison below to access the associated guide.

What’s Next?

If you’re looking for golf irons, whether they are forged or cast irons, check out our golf iron reviews below:

Happy golfing!